Rodgers Vs Favre Poll
+2
[iS] smilingdonkie
[iS] samurai8juicebox
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Favre or Rodgers
Rodgers Vs Favre Poll
Who's better Rodgers vs Favre. Remember. Don't vote as favorite, vote as stats, super bowls, age, etc.
I chose Favre because he was 38 or 39, played with a wore down Ankle, played with a team that wasn't good without him(They had a D-Line, and a RB without him, thats it), and makes it to the NFC Championship, only to be stopped by the Saints bounty program. His career was judged by one single interception in the NFC Championship in 09 or 10. When he was in his prime he had one of the best arms in the NFL besides Manning. He could take a couple hits in the pocket. He was 1-1 in the SB.
Rodgers is close because he had a team that had some pretty good players and a good head coach. He got drafted first round. He played behind the best QB in the league for a few years. He could learn from Favre. He threw 4,000 yards for like 3 straight years. He has one of the best QBRs in the league. He's 1-0 in the SB. But the season they go undeafeated or cose to it they lose in the playoffs. And, a main reason i chose favre, is because can rodgers make it to the playoffs(NFC Championship) when he is past his prime in his late 30's. Can he take the hits Favre took. So in 5-10 years, we'll know.
VOTE!
I chose Favre because he was 38 or 39, played with a wore down Ankle, played with a team that wasn't good without him(They had a D-Line, and a RB without him, thats it), and makes it to the NFC Championship, only to be stopped by the Saints bounty program. His career was judged by one single interception in the NFC Championship in 09 or 10. When he was in his prime he had one of the best arms in the NFL besides Manning. He could take a couple hits in the pocket. He was 1-1 in the SB.
Rodgers is close because he had a team that had some pretty good players and a good head coach. He got drafted first round. He played behind the best QB in the league for a few years. He could learn from Favre. He threw 4,000 yards for like 3 straight years. He has one of the best QBRs in the league. He's 1-0 in the SB. But the season they go undeafeated or cose to it they lose in the playoffs. And, a main reason i chose favre, is because can rodgers make it to the playoffs(NFC Championship) when he is past his prime in his late 30's. Can he take the hits Favre took. So in 5-10 years, we'll know.
VOTE!
[iS] samurai8juicebox- Honored Guest
- Steam : samurai8juicebox
PSN Name : samurai8juicebox
Posts : 1600
Pointz : 25916
Join date : 2011-11-27
Location : Somewhere but not here
Re: Rodgers Vs Favre Poll
[iS] smilingdonkie wrote:Ryan Leaf is better than both of them combined
lmao.
Also, I think Farve in his prime was better. Tom Brady is still the man. But yeah, Farve over Rodgers.
[iS] Trent- Jebussssss
- Status : HAI, I'M TRENT.
Posts : 4083
Pointz : 30707
Join date : 2010-12-09
Age : 32
Location : Gainesville, FL
Re: Rodgers Vs Favre Poll
I think Rodgers is admired more by older men, like the analysts on those boring NFL pregame shows, because Rodgers represents the old school quarterback-- perfect mechanics, not a great runner, pocket passer, etc.
I think younger people, like Trent for example, like Favre because he is a badass-- great quarterback, but also could potentially win the toughest man award.
it's difficult to decide because you have credible sources, like the old men analysts, that prefer Rodgers, but pretty much every young person likes Favre.
Both are great, but I think Favre's legacy puts him ahead. If Rodgers has a year like 2011 for the rest of his career, he will pass everyone
I think younger people, like Trent for example, like Favre because he is a badass-- great quarterback, but also could potentially win the toughest man award.
it's difficult to decide because you have credible sources, like the old men analysts, that prefer Rodgers, but pretty much every young person likes Favre.
Both are great, but I think Favre's legacy puts him ahead. If Rodgers has a year like 2011 for the rest of his career, he will pass everyone
Re: Rodgers Vs Favre Poll
The only reason I voted Rodgers was because unlike Favre, his passes seem to be more smooth and he seems to be in real good control for his age. Considering that as good as Peyton Manning is, Manning is just 36. So I honestly do expect Rodgers to surpass Favre.
R3aCT- Status : Quit website
Posts : 5
Pointz : 21132
Join date : 2012-08-24
Re: Rodgers Vs Favre Poll
Farve has proved himself over and over again. I cant compare, maybe when Rodgers retires! ELI OR DIE!!!!! NYG!!!!! FTW!!!!!!!
Similar topics
» Better Poll Than Luke's Poll
» POLL OF THE DAY!
» POLL OF THE DAY
» Poll of the Day
» poll of the day 20-4
» POLL OF THE DAY!
» POLL OF THE DAY
» Poll of the Day
» poll of the day 20-4
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|